She Wanted To Be A Girl

Photo: Mark Calleja
Standard

When a 9-year-old child came out as a transgender individual, her parents supported her need to be socially recognised as the gender she identified with. Her grades improved, she was no longer getting suspended and she kept the friends she made. It all went well until one thing happened: The girl’s parents were told that she had to use toilets for the disabled, which were not gendered. This is the point where one might ask: Why would there be a problem if queer individuals used toilets for the disabled instead? How can this be perceived as discrimination?

Forcing someone who is queer to use disabled toilets would bring us back to the time when queer individuals were perceived as being mentally disabled. However, as most of us would know in the 21st century, transgender people are no longer considered mentally ill by the American Psychiatric Association (APA). Even if members of the education institution may not have perceived the child as one who was disabled, or simply suggested that the child could use toilets for the disabled out of convenience, it could easily be interpreted as saying queer individuals are mentally disabled. That’s why it can be offensive. It was an excuse for the institution not to build unisex toilets, but it was an excuse that can harm many others.

The act of entering a female toilet was the child’s way of expressing her gender identity. It was only awkward because everyone knew the child was born male, but things would have been even worse if she was forced to use either the male toilets. Imagine if the child was so uncomfortable with walking into the boy’s toilets that she had to hold things in for too long; imagine if boys scoffed or laughed at her; imagine if boys started feeling uncomfortable about having a girl enter their private space too.

If people who identify with the gender they were assigned with with have the right to use toilets comfortably, then so should all who identify as queer. We all have the right to be who we want to be and express that freely. Obviously, we need to bring this practice of having unisex toilets beyond just primary schools into bigger educational institutions such as universities. Unisex toilets need to be built for the safety and wellbeing of queer individuals. We must make sure they are not negatively affected from a young age, or for a long time, including their time in university. Three to five years is not short.

Want more information? Have a look at the news article published on The Australian. This case prompted the Queensland Government to plan for the installation of unisex toilets in schools.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “She Wanted To Be A Girl

  1. georgiakevin

    I have never understood how a girl who is transsexual who uses the Ladies room can be a threat to anyone. All that girl wants to do is to take care of things and maybe if she is older refresh her make up. I have known genetic girls who look more masculine than feminine go in to the Ladies Room and no one says anything. How sad for society when we treat a group of people as poorly as we do the transgendered community.

    Like

    • Skip To The Loo at UNSW

      It is unfortunate that queer and transgender people are more likely to be abused than cisgendered people, even in toilets. It’s unfair that some can’t even fulfil their basic needs without feeling uncomfortable or afraid.

      Like

    • Skip To The Loo at UNSW

      Hence why I think people shouldn’t eliminate gendered toilets. Cis gendered people have as much right to use toilets comfortably as queer or transgender people do. I just think unisex toilets need to be built for queer and trans people alongside the gendered toilets, so that anyone who entered unisex toilets would be fully aware that they have to share that toilet with people of different genders.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s